2nd SUNDAY OF LENT
FEBRUARY 25, 2024
Gen. 22: 1-2, 9a, 10-13, 15-18;
Ps 116; Rom. 8: 31b-34; Mark 9: 2-10
by Jude Siciliano, OP
are times in our lives when we have a mountain-top experience and we can easily
use Peter’s words to describe it. “Lord it is good that we are here.” These
moments are be very special: at our own wedding, or the wedding of someone we
love; a new job that fulfills a dream; getting into the college of our first
choice; retirement after years of hard work and saving.
AND there are everyday experiences when we can also say, “Lord is good that we
are here”: watching our child take his/her first steps; holidays with the whole
family around the table and everyone getting along; having coffee with our best
friend; good seats at the opening of the baseball season; watching a grandchild
perform at a kindergarten play, making the high school soccer team. These are
moments when we feel we are on a mountain top and we can say with Peter, “It is
good that we are here.” And we thank God for these times.
But our lives aren’t always as comfortable as Peter describes. We have
experiences when we can’t say, “It is good that we are here.” In fact, there are
times when we don’t want to be “here”– and would rather be anywhere else: not
sick; not without a job; not struggling with relationships; not failing at
school; not in the process of a divorce; not undergoing chemotherapy; not in the
wrong job. After Mass this past Sunday, a woman asked me to pray for her sister
who just found out she has brain cancer. She said to me, “It is a nightmare!”
(Won’t you join me and pray for that woman’s ailing sister too?) These are
hardly mountain-top experiences - during these times we could hardly say, “It is
good that we are here.” We would prefer to say, “I want out!”
For the ancient peoples, and even in some places today, mountains are special
meeting places with God. “To go up a mountain” was a term used for those seeking
a special relationship with God. That is what happened with Peter, James and
John when they went up the mountain with Jesus. They had a new insight into who
he was and they heard the voice that directed them to listen to Jesus – to
listen to him, not just on the mountain top, but for the rest of their lives.
Listen to what he said about God’s love for us; listen to him when we need
reassurance that we are forgiven; listen to him for how to treat others, even
those we call enemies; listen to him for his concern for the poor and the
What would listening to Jesus mean at this moment of our lives? It’s Lent - and
many of us have chosen to give up some favorite things – candy, movies, alcohol,
special treats – these are good practices. They keep us conscious of God and
help us maintain our priorities. The voice on the mountain said, “Listen to
him.” Which this Lent might mean not only giving up something – but also taking
the money we save - $10, 30, 40 and giving it to a soup kitchen, an outreach
program, a homeless shelter, the parish food pantry, a community organization
that helps children, or the unemployed, etc. This too is a way of following the
voice on the mountaintop and listening to Jesus.
People say that time is money – so we could take our valuable time and use it to
visit someone who is ailing, alone, grieving, or struggling. We could use our
time to make phone calls we have been putting off. Lenten activities like these,
we hope, will last beyond Lent. It is just good advice to listen to Jesus, no
matter what time of year; but with our hectic schedules and the competing and
distracting voices in our world drawing our attention elsewhere, it is sometimes
hard to hear him, to know he is with us and to know what we are to do.
We, like the disciples, periodically need to go to a listening place, our own
private “mountain top.” That could be a lenten discipline for us – to find some
quiet time to listen to Jesus through his Word. We could do that by ourselves,
by setting aside a few minutes each day to read and meditate on the scriptures.
If our parish is offering a Lenten scripture series we might want to attend and,
with other disciples, “listen to Jesus.” We don’t have to travel very far to
find a mountain top to listen to Jesus.
The Abraham and Isaac story is fearsome, isn’t it? We are told that “God put
Abraham to the test.” In Genesis, Abraham and Sarah endure ten trials or tests.
But today’s is the most severe: God orders Abraham to offer his son Isaac as a
holocaust, a sacrifice to God. In Judaism this story is known as “Akedah,” “the
binding” and is a central narrative in Jewish theology, spirituality and
God calls Abraham by name. He responds, “Here I am.” That is a repetitious
exchange throughout the Bible: God calls a person by name for a specific task
and they respond, “Here I am” – then they wait for God to speak. The person’s
response suggests readiness, receptivity and a willingness to follow
instructions. But what a request God makes of Abraham after calling him by name!
When a friend calls our name and asks a favor, do we suspect such a demanding
request will be put upon us, as God puts on Abraham?
To make matters worse – as if to underline the cost of the sacrifice being asked
of him – God emphasizes Abraham’s relationship with his son, “Take your son,
your only one, whom you love....” This story is getting tense! Imagine how a
modern congregation will hear it in the light of crimes in our society and
church against children.
You can’t help but wonder how Abraham, who protested God’s intention to destroy
the innocent with the guilty in Sodom (Gen. 18: 22-33), would ever begin to
respond to this horrendous request to sacrifice his son, “your only son, whom
you love.” The location of the “height,” Moriah, God will point out to Abraham
is unknown. We can see where the story is leading us: later in Chronicles the
Temple mount in Jerusalem is called “Moriah.” God will be worshiped and
sacrifice will be offered in Jerusalem, at Moriah. Of course, still later, the
innocent and much-loved child, Christ, will be crucified in Jerusalem.
Abraham and Sarah have placed all their hopes on the child, who was a sign of
God’s promise that they would have descendants as numerous as the stars in the
heavens and the grains of sand on the beach. People in the congregation, upon
hearing this story, will be confused and even repulsed by the story and wonder
how one can relate in a personal way to this God?
Not a very comfortable, or tame God, is it? This is the God who invites us into
a relationship and strengthens us to respond with faith and trust to what is
asked of us. It is very hard to live with questions and to let God be God.
Abraham’s God is not easily contained or tamed by our attempts to reduce God to
a more manageable size. The Genesis text today is uncompromising. What we get is
Abraham – who is unwavering and unquestioning as he sets out to do what God told
him. He doesn’t ask how God will fulfill a covenant, while taking away the very
child who was the sign and future fulfillment of that covenant. One of the
questions put to the community in this story: Is God trustworthy when there is
not concrete evidence to prove it and when any sign of reassurance we thought we
had, is taken away?
You have to admire the boldness of the author who put this story in the
narrative and the biblical editors who placed Genesis, with this story intact,
at the beginning of the Bible. Very early believers are asked if we want to
worship a God of mystery; a God who is outside any little box we might want to
put God into. Previously Abraham had failed at crucial moments to trust God.
Still, God did not give up on him. Now Abraham cant’ fudge – will he trust God
despite the catastrophic demand being placed on him?
The biblical narrative shows that since creation human beings had moved further
and further from God. In the Abraham-Isaac narrative we see that God is forging
a new relationship, a covenant, with humans and Abraham is the model for us all.
We discover in the biblical tale that God is passionate and loving and will not
leave us on our own; no matter how many times we have failed, no matter what
impossible tests we face now or in the future.
The biblical commentators offer us some help in understanding the Abraham-Isaac
story. They suggest it is a repudiation of the Canaanite practice of human
sacrifice. The God of the Israelites will not require such acts of worship, or
proof of dedication. That lesson certainly comes across vividly in the “binding
of Isaac.” The story also touches into the persecution the Chosen People endured
throughout history. Like Abraham, despite what was asked of them, they would
cast themselves into the hands of their God.
Click here for a link to this Sunday’s readings: