"FIRST IMPRESSIONS"

FEAST OF ALL SAINTS

Rev. 7: 2-4, 9-14; Psalm 24; I John 3:1-3; Matthew 5:1-12a

By: Jude Siciliano, OP

Dear Preachers:

I have to be honest with you: I find the Beatitudes difficult preaching. They are so lofty, so frequently quoted, so over-used for all kinds of occasions; the stuff of epithets on cemetery gates. They are quoted like poetry and filled with popular sentimentalism. People have heard them before--- so familiar and therefore----a challenge for the preacher.

In addition to their familiarity, there’s the problem of what preaching strategy to use. You certainly don’t want to go down the list and comment on each beatitude. The preacher risks trivializing and overloading —it’s just too much for the hearers to grasp and keep in focus. (Imagine the hearers clicking off on their fingers the nine beatitudes as you work your way through the list!) There is a problem of interpretation as well. The Beatitudes shouldn’t be used as a New Testament equivalent of the 10 Commandments. Jesus is not saying, "You must be poor in spirit, so that you can receive the reign of God....etc". The disciple who lives these beatitudes is not doing so in order to win God’s favor and reward. It is possible to live these beatitudes only as a response to what God has done in and for us. That’s the way it was with the former testament; God acted first and the chosen people responded.

The first word of the beatitudes lays out their spirit; the people Jesus is addressing are being assured, even congratulated. Despite their pain and suffering, they are already "blessed." They don’t have to wait for some future congratulatory judgment, they have it already. These are the poor, the "no-accounts" of society. This is the first time anyone has ever called them "blessed." These are not the kind of people whom their contemporaries would consider "fortunate," or congratulate them for their current state, the way Jesus is doing. God has gifted a people and Jesus affirms that gift when he blesses those before him. He says the blessing and those around him are the recipients of this blessing, "Blessed are they who...."

Did Jesus confuse his tenses? Did he mean to say, not "Blessed are they...," but rather, "Blessed will they be..."? Wouldn’t the future tense make more sense for reward because he is speaking to people who are presently in dire straits? He calls them "blessed." Somehow those who have turned to Jesus, though they experience suffering and even persecution, their life with Jesus is "blessed." That doesn’t mean things are right or just for them, or that evil should not be struggled against. Yet, those linked to Jesus share in the very life of blessedness that was his. He is the one who was poor in spirit, merciful, meek, single hearted and a peacemaker. One notices in these beatitudes that Jesus is first of all describing himself--- he enfleshes the beatitudes.

Let’s make this harder still. The argument is often leveled that the beatitudes reinforce a passive and even a victim-mentality. They seem to describe "milk toast" disciples who simply take what comes their way, and offer no resistance to evil done them (after all they are "meek" aren’t they?). They are just holding out for some future promised reward. But Jesus is not calling people to be victims. He is blessing those who follow him and, as a consequence, suffer.

Suppose the beatitudes don’t describe virtues of different types of disciples. Suppose instead we look at them as a unit, as descriptions of the follower of Christ. This follower, the poor one, has placed confidence and trust in God and not in any human power. Such a person would be already rich in Jesus’ eyes, for that one’s life is in good hands, more secure than any other security they might try to provide for themselves. Then, the one trusting and looking to God, is filled with a burning desire to see things right. The translation from our Lectionary is, "...who hunger and thirst for holiness." However, another translation has it, "...who hunger and thirst for righteousness." Later they are described as "persecuted for holiness (righteousness) sake." These are people, Jesus says, who have the reign of God already and have a passion to see things set right, to see life here reflecting God’s will for us and all people.

These "poor in spirit" are not sitting on their hands looking to the clouds. They are working to set things right by showing others mercy, making peace, staying fixed with "their eye on the prize," despite the persecutions they must endure. They truly are "single hearted," having no false gods to distract them from their course.

In some ways, if we really heard the beatitudes we would need to read no further in the gospels. They convey the whole gospel message for us: Jesus, "God with us," has enfleshed these beatitudes, lives them to the fullness. Those who accept him and his message have their lives transformed and their vision cleared. Now they see things in another perspective; they live in a trusting relationship to a God they know to be a loving parent who wants to establish a new human community among them. These disciples have a completely different way of seeing and living with one another; they live under a very different rule called, the reign of God. As citizens of this reign they dedicate themselves to it and invite others into the same reign, under the same loving God. Because of Jesus’ life given for them, the beatitudes shape and empower their way of life. Thus, like him, they experience insults and persecution. Their lives are not free of pain; but their strength to continue comes from the one who has declared them already "blessed" and holds their present blessedness secure for them.

Click here for a link to this Holy Day's readings:

Rev. 7: 2-4, 9-14; Psalm 24; I John 3:1-3; Matthew 5:1-12a